Four answers arrive before you have decided anything.
Yes, sweetheart, which you do not entirely mean anymore. What do you think, which is a dodge and she can hear that it is one. Some people believe there is and some people do not, which is true and lands like a weather report. Or a short speech about how the important thing is that we love each other, delivered to a person who is seven and did not ask about that.
My kid asked if God is real, said the way parents say it to me, usually comes with about three seconds of decision time attached. What I hear most often is that they answered too fast, and then lay awake rewriting it.
So before anything else, the useful thing to know is that you can buy time and it costs you nothing.
Find Out What Made Her Ask
That is a really good question. What made you think about it?
Ask that first, every time, at every age. Not as a stall, though it works as one. Ask it because the question almost never arrives out of nowhere, and what prompted it usually tells you which question you are actually being asked.
A friend said something at school and she wants to know if the friend is right. Somebody died. She saw a picture in a book at a grandparent’s house. She has just worked out that the tooth fairy was you, and she is running an audit on everything else in the category, which is a reasonable thing to do and gets its own week at Week 22. Or she is six and she thought of it in the bath, which also happens.
Those are five different conversations. Answering the metaphysics when she asked about her friend is a way of missing the child entirely while appearing to take her seriously.
My Kid Asked If God Is Real and the Word Real Is Doing a Lot of Work
The part that makes this harder than it should be is the shape the question arrives in.
The question arrives in a shape. Is God real sounds like is a giraffe real, or is a dragon real. It assumes God is the kind of thing that either sits somewhere in the universe or does not, and that the honest answer is one of two words.
That shape came from somewhere. It is the sky-god shape, the old man above the clouds, and most of us got handed it before we could evaluate it. If that is the only available meaning of the word God, then a lot of thoughtful people are going to answer no, and they will be answering accurately about the thing they were given.
Which is why yes and no both feel wrong in your mouth. You are being asked to affirm or deny a picture you already stopped believing, and neither option is honest.
What I Would Say, and I Will Own This as Mine
My own answer is that God is not a very large person located somewhere. My reading, argued at length elsewhere and offered here as mine rather than as the position you have to take, is that God is love. Not a being who happens to be loving. Love itself, and wherever love is actually happening at cost to somebody, that is the thing I mean by the word.
That answer has one great advantage with children and one real difficulty.
The advantage is that a four year old has never seen a sky worth trusting, and she has seen love, in this kitchen, this week. Love is the most concrete thing in her life. It is considerably easier to point at than a man in the clouds ever was, and Week 12 is entirely about how to do that.
The difficulty is that it does not answer her question in the shape she asked it, and a seven year old will notice. Which is fine. Telling a child that a question is bigger than the two answers available is not a dodge, as long as you say what you do think afterward.
How to Say It at Three Ages
Ages 3 to 6. Short, concrete, and true. I think God is real, and what I mean by God is love. Every time somebody is kind to you, that is the realest thing I know about. If your honest answer is that you are not sure, say that in the same voice. I am not sure, and I think about it a lot. A four year old is not evaluating your theology. She is watching your face to see whether this is a frightening topic.
Ages 7 to 12. This age can hold a question staying open, and can hold that you have a position without it being final. Different people answer that in really different ways, and here is what I think and why. Then tell her, in about four sentences, and stop. Then ask what she thinks and take the answer seriously even when it is strange, because at nine she is doing real work and the strangeness is part of it.
Ages 13 and up. Give her the actual state of your thinking, including the parts you have not resolved. A teenager can smell a tidied-up version. Tell her what you have concluded and what you gave up and what you still miss about believing the older version, if you miss it. Week 18 is about the direct form of this, which is when she asks what you believe rather than what is true.
If Your Answer Is No
Some of you would say no, and this series is not going to talk you out of it.
That answer is available and it is honest and there is nothing dishonorable in it. What I would ask is that you give it the same way I am asking believing parents to give theirs, which is as your position rather than as the settled result. I do not think there is a God, and plenty of people I respect disagree with me, and you will get to work out what you think.
The reason is not fairness for its own sake. It is that a child handed a closed answer in either direction has been handed a closed answer, and the whole argument of this series is that the closing is what did the damage. A confident no can shut down a nine year old’s thinking as efficiently as a confident yes ever did.
You do not owe her certainty you do not have.
Questions Parents Ask About This
Is it okay to tell my child I do not know if God is real?
Yes, and it is usually better than a confident answer you do not mean. Children tend to be better at detecting a performance than at evaluating theology. Saying you do not know also models the thing you want, which is that a person can hold an open question without falling apart.
What if my answer is different from my spouse’s?
Say so plainly rather than presenting a united front you do not have. Your dad and I think about this differently, and we both love you, is a sentence a six year old can carry. Week 47 takes up the fuller version of that situation, which is one of the most common in this audience.
What age do children start asking this?
In my experience it clusters somewhere between four and seven, often right after a death, a move, or the Santa question. But there is no schedule, some children ask at three and some never ask directly at all, and a child who has not asked is not behind.
What if she asks the same question again next week?
Answer it again. Repeated asking usually means she is working, not that your first answer failed. It can also mean something specific is worrying her that she has not named yet, which is another good reason to ask what made her think of it.
Next week we take the answer I gave above and make it usable, which means working out how you actually teach a small child that God is love without quietly rebuilding the old man in the sky out of nicer materials.
About Pastor Brad Jagger
Pastor Brad Jagger is Senior Pastor of Windermere Union Church (UCC) in Windermere, Florida, a community committed to Love Above All. He writes about faith, doubt, deconstruction, belonging, and raising children who never have to be afraid of God.
If you are raising kids after leaving the faith you grew up in, and you want a church where questions are welcome, people are affirmed, and nobody has to pretend to have it all figured out, learn more at windermereunion.org.
Pastor Brad Jagger | Windermere Union Church | Love Above All
